The hardest quick little posts to write are the ones about the biggest issues. We've all -- in the queer community, for sure, but certainly at Out -- been talking about the movie Milk for more than a year now. For some who have been working to make this dream of a film into reality, that's more like 30 years.
When we first started exploring coverage, I got a call from longtime PR expert and Out 100 alum Howard Bragman, who told me a story about one early attempt by Warner Bros. to develop the film. In true political spirit they called a town hall meeting in San Francisco to discuss their plans -- only to hear, and loudly, from as many different gay perspectives as there were people in the room.
Any film is truly made by committee, but if it's done right none of the scotch tape shows. Milk is done right, and it's our movie, a movie made by no small number of gay people to celebrate our slain hero, a man whose most simple and dying wish was that we all come out, come out, wherever we are. That one little word, out, is at the heart of everything we do here -- even when it just looks like silly gay jokes or slick fashion spreads. We all believe the world is a better place when we are out, and that our collective and individual impact on culture is best achieved from a place of clear, closet-free creativity.
I don't even know what else to say to convince you to go see this, if somehow you are still on the fence about it. Milk is a marvelously restrained film about an iconic figure who was also just a guy, a funny, dorky, smart, terrified guy who really didn't give a shit if you thought he was too loud or proud or ahead of his times. I admit I cried through a lot of the film -- from the opening scenes, actually, what seem to be archival footage of people hiding their faces as they are arrested in bar raids simply for having the temerity to have a drink in the company of their own kind.
But also I think it's important to say how much all the crying I did was not really about the tragedy of Harvey Milk's death, or even about the lost opportunities or momentum we might have had were he still alive. Despite the obvious, violent finale of his story, it didn't have the full pathetic whammy of Brokeback Mountain. It was an awful, ugly way for Harvey Milk to meet his end. But he was, unfortunately, far from the only queer person to lose his life because he refused to lie about who he was, and his death was by no means the only legacy he has left us.
This was also not a movie where it was possible, should you sometimes to be required to do this kind of thing as a part of your job, to count how many gay kisses there were. (I lost track about three minutes in.) It is, finally, a movie where all of the millions of ways that queer people have and seek affection just like anyone else in the world are shown just that simply. When it is a momentous, meaningful occasion for two men to kiss, it is that important on screen as well. When it is seductive, it is seductive. What this movie -- performed mostly by straight men playing gay and a couple of gay men playing very straight -- is not is contrived.
It's still just a movie, and seeing it doesn't replace all the other hard, boring, annoying work that's required on the road to full equality. But it's a good stop along the way, a beautiful tribute to both a man and a movement, and it's about goddamned time.
For more from Out:
> Milk Man: James Franco is totally dreamy in the movie, playing longtime Milk boyfriend Scott Smith. Here's his conversation with screenwriter Dustin Lance Black from our November issue. (See? Dreamy.)
> On Set with the Men Behind Milk: Our behind-the-scenes look at the making of the movie.
> The Out 100: There are six men among this year's honorees, including Artist of the Year Gus Van Sant. Read about them all here.
Plus -- come back Monday for an exclusive look at the fashion of the film.
Have a good Thanksgiving, everyone, and have a little hope.












Recent Comments
Golden Girls pack up, Lifetime vs. Bravo